
Boyish is having some issues. Identity issues. In the car a couple weeks ago his sister was talking about Ishara, a girl in her class, and Boyish piped up from the backseat: “Mommy, is she white?”
“Who? Ishara? I don’t think so.”
“She’s not,” Girlish said.
“Is she black then?”
“Yeah, Ishara’s black,” Girlish said.
“Am I black?”
I glanced at Goodlooking, who was grinning. “Sort of,” I said.
“Am I white?”
“Well, you’re white like Mommy and black like Daddy,” I said. “You’re lucky, because you’re both.”
And we left it, for the moment.
Goodlooking and I have talked about this, and our general approach has been not to discuss race with the children. We don’t have deep discussions about skin color, or multiracial identity, or blackness, or whiteness, because it’s something that doesn’t matter to us, as a family. He’s my man, and they’re our kids. They look a little like me, and a little like him—just like most everybody who has a biological family.
It comes in, though, occasionally, and when it does we do talk about it, minimizing its importance as best we can. Girlish thinks of herself as black, I think. She identifies strongly with her paternal grandmother, and with Goodlooking’s family in general. Boyish has informed us, however, that he doesn’t want to be black—or rather—that he’s not black, as if he has some control over it. Last night he had a friend over for dinner, and Boyish sat next to me at the table insisting that he was white, like me, and Girlish was black, like Daddy.
I held my arm next to his. “You’re darker than me,” I said, “maybe you’re honey? Maybe you’re light brown?”
He shook his head. No. Then later, when I wasn’t around, but within earshot of his Daddy, he asked his English buddy, “Elias, are you white?”
After a bit of confused silence, Elias answered that he was.
“I’m white, too,” Boyish said, “but I’m dark white.”